Monday, 17 July 2017

Refuge: Transforming a broken refugee system.- intro and chapter 1.

  • Authors - Alexander Betts- political scientist, Paul Collier- Economist. 
  • There goal' has been to writes for a generalist audience , to engage intelligent and interested member of the public keen to understand the origins of the ' refugee crisis' and explore with us ideas for a workable solution.' 
  • ' It seeks to rock with the constraints and opportunities of the contemporary world and channel them into a system that can provide refugees with autonomy and dignity.'  
  • 2015, spark in large refugee numbers coming from the poorest parts of the world to some of the richest.
  • Mass violence in Syrian 2011- the civilians involved mainly moved to countries like Jordan , Lebanon and Turkey, however this then offers limited options.
  • Only when 700 people drowned crossing to Lampedusa ( Italian island) did the media start to pay attention and claim it to be a ' global refugee crisis.'
  • Total that year 3,000 from drowning. 
  • Migrant Smuggling- by gangs.
  • 2016 Europe effectively dose it's doors.
  • Not allowed work.
The purpose of refuge:
  • 1648- treaty of Westphalia- ' refuge entails..., when face serious harm at home , they should be allowed to flee and receive access to a safe haven , at least until they can go home or be permanently reintegrated else where.' 
  • Cold War Iron curtain- 

















  • 'Eurocentrasim'
  • the rules apply to the people fleeing from persecution but not disorder.
  • UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) built camps, but they unincidentally turned into percent resting places.
  • '...refuge is about fulfilling a duty of rescue. Born out of out common humanity, it is based on the simple recognition that we have shared obligation towards our fellow human beings.
  • Entitiled to expect 3 things: rescue, autonomy ' route out of limbo.'
  • 'Contary to popular belief , most refugees are not in camps, over half now live in large cities like Nairobi, Johannesburgh.
  • Half world's refugees in ' protracted refugee situations.' Two decades average stay-'people are born into camps, grow up in camps and become adults in camps.'
  •  lack of support from international community.
The need for a new approach"
  • Status quo changing.
  • Cold War: Extremist religions has replaces extremist ideologies. 
  • 'It has to be about restoring people's autonomy through jobs and education...'
  • Different models for different countries. not one size fits all. 
  • Dag Hammarskjold- ' was not created to take mankind to heaven, but to save humanity from hell.' 
Part 1 - Why is there a crisis? :

  • To be a refugee you have to cross an international border however many who are fleeing the violence are not in a position to do that so they are Displaced NOT Refugee.
  • number of people displaced - 65.3 million.
  • 'Global modernity has not only produced technological miracles like the iPhone , and more than 1, 800 billionaires , it has broken all records for the human tragedies that constitute displacement.' 
  • Rich ge richer and the poor get poorer concept ?
what drives refugee displacement ?
  • 'people seeking refuge are not fleeing poverty , they are fleeing danger.'
  • 1935-45 - rise of fascim- dangerous for Jews.
  • Creating huge civilian dislocation.
  • society collapse into mass violence.
  • Legitimacy
  • Fragility.
  • Democracy 
  • Libya- Colonel Gaddafi.
  • Gaddafi over throne , country did not develop but defended into violent rivalry.
  • 'A third factor leading to increases in fragility is technology.'
  • tear gas, phone tapping.
  • social media.
  • chance forms of social protest.
  • Obama- Yes we can! campain.
  • social media confronted state violence.
  • links countries and people together.
  • Another factor price of natural resources ' super cycle.' - up to 2013.
  • Nicolas Berman- geo-referenced all the mineral resources extracted in Africa , unlike them geographically to outbreaks of organised violence...' 
  • Arab Spring- linked claimed partially to the super cycle.




Islamic Extremism:
  • less military more exposed to far worse mass violence.
  • Mass violence , lack of milliarty , ISIS.
  • 'fat tail phenomenon'?
  • ISIS- situation greatly amplified by Russian bombing.
  • Yemen - worst global displace meant of 2015.
  • extreme example for flight, German Jews.
  • Boko Haram.
  • Refugees are not migrants.
  • Top countries that refugees flee to in the past 4 decades:
  • Pakistan.
  • Iran.
  • Ethiopia 
  • kenya
  • Uganda.
  • Tanzania.
  • all countries of emigration but also close by.
  • key message for these part-
  • 'The underlying process of refugee generation is clear enough: a large group of fragile states is each exposed to a small but significant risk that it will implode into mass violence against civilians that generates displacement . Many of these displace will probably remain in their own countries , but many others will seek havens beyond the borders.' 

No comments:

Post a Comment