In satirical comedy series Spitting image Margret Thatcher is portrayed in her usual stereotypical
ways of witch like features and crooked nose, but one significant visual change
is that she is dressed in a suite. This could
be seen as Thatcher, a powerful female leader conforming to the masculinity or ‘ The default man’ (Perry,TheDesentOfMan,p14,2016 ) .
Given that politics is a male dominated profession as a woman coming into it
you need to fight to be heard, so conforming to their way of acting and dressing
could be the only way to be taken seriously. It took politicians a while to
take Margret Thatcher seriously. So as a result it was suggested that she had
voice coaching in order to make her voice deeper lower and more authoritative
for public speaking, more male and dominant. She has to meet parliaments embedded
ideals of how a politician should behave and act. Spitting image really highlights this fact up in it sketches but
also dose still show her as a powerful figure and above the men in her cabinet
for example ‘ Margaret Thatcher’s cabinet
of vegetables ‘ (Spitting image,(1984-96),
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPzzgE34YQY, date viewed (17/12/16). the
waitress ask what Thatcher ( who she refers to as sir) wants a raw stake. Then
say ‘what about the vegetables’ Spitting
image,(1984-96), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPzzgE34YQY, date viewed (17/12/16).
, Thatcher thinks she is referring to her all male cabinet and says they will
have the same as me. This belittles and makes the male politicians appear
stupid, therefore making Thatcher appear more intelligent than her peers. It also
is still portraying the ruthlessness of Thatcher too as she orders a raw stake,
like a vicious predator would eat. Spitting
images aim was to reflect popular public opinion back onto the public in order
to get them more engaged with politics. And During the 80’s it was a time of upheaval
but now politicians are more protected from satirical comedy and don’t tend to
offer as much to bounce off. However the internet and social media allows
anyone to do satire for example the sorry song which was a collection of Nick
Clegg saying sorry to a tune. But it
would be so good for another show like spitting image on TV mainly to make
people more in tune with politics and this may lead people to see the floors
like a lack of diversity within our own parliament which leads to certain sectors
of people like women and black people being poorly represented.
Saturday, 17 December 2016
Friday, 16 December 2016
Grayson Perry - Images responding to male societal sectors.
These two pieces have been created by Grayson Perry in
response to how male centred politics and the financial system are.
The sculpture named ‘ Object in Foreground’ is coved in bank notes , leading bankers and
politicians. George Osborne for example who features multiple times . His aim
behind it ‘ I was thinking of an object
that could hold its own among all the marble but drew attention to the unquestioned
maleness of its world’(Perry,(date viewed
16/12/16 ),http://www.cityam.com/) There is an aspect of school boy humour in
this piece , and this works ironically along with the male dominant culture
that Perry states occurs in these sectors. It also suggests that it is quite an
alpha male environment but it is taking this in a humours tone with this too. The
images are spread hectically throughout the image and these reflect the busy environment
Perry has based the work on but they are also quite dulled down colours on the
imagery used. This could again be another reflection dull way business and men
of power in a very generic way. However there could be said that there is juxtaposition
to the piece as it is made out of clay and this is a fragile material. So it
could be saying about the under fragility of an alpha male.
The Wood cut entitled ‘ Animal Sprit’ consists of a half
bear man , half bull which also has a massive phallus. This is a power image,
the half bull aspect represents a powerful and male animal, also represents
Hegemonic masculinity. The bear too is a powerful animal and the creature is standing powerfully over the city and a baby, this also shows that it has a status of power and control. The big phallus in
both images also give the suggestion that the bigger it is the more of a man
you are. ‘ There’s no disputing what it
is… it’s a big cock’ (Perry,(date viewed
16/12/16 ),http://www.cityam.com/) This piece is also meant to be displayed
within the same environment as the sculpture. And also the material of wood is
a strong material and the fact that that each line had to be etched into it
could reflect the strength of labour.
Men, Suicide and Society- a report by the samaritans.
‘…the fact remains that it is men who die far more by
suicide than women’(Samaritans,(2012),p1)
.A
report issued by The Samaritans investigates the causes into a rise in the
amount of middle aged male’s committing suicide. One of the causes the report covers
is Masculinities. It states that the way men are brought up , told how to
behave and roles that are expected from them in society. Men end up comparing themselves against ‘ a masculine
‘gold standard’ which prizes power, control and invincibility.’ (Samaritans,(2012),p1) When men have the belief that they are not
meeting this societal standard then there self esteem drops and they feel
defeat. Having the job of being the house provider and head of the family is
essentical to ‘being a man’ (Samaritans,(2012),p1)
, and this is a trait noticed
particularly with working class men. So
when a man looses this control this brings him to suicidal behaviour , through
drugs and alcohol as a way of gaining back control. The report explains that’
Masculinity and femininity are sociological concepts which can be defined through
a collection of roles, behaviours , activities, expressions and practises…constructed
ideas about ‘being a man’ or ‘being a women’ (Samaritans,(2012),p1)
Hegemonic
masculinity is a theory set out by
Raewyn Connell .’ …it is an ideal to which most men aspire and / or against which
they measure themselves.’ (Samaritans,(2012),p10)
It is characterised through several
attributes for example power hungry, aggressiveness, independency, success, activity
and control. And as a result men are discouraged to show any forms of anxiety,
burdens and difficulties. He or She which is a feminist campain also campain
for men rights too, they want to give men more support in to open up about their
emotions and not to feel weak by doing so, instead of bottling up. However from
this report it looks like society could easily be said to be a fault. It needs to update it values but this is a
hard thing to as it seems that the ideal of masculinity is too deeply embedded.
So by adding more women into powerful places like parliament would mean that
some male MPs would lose their jobs and could be said to be at risk of feeling defeated
and without purpose. However could this be an impactful way of changing society
values, but sacking male MPs and adding in female ones?
Thursday, 15 December 2016
definition - Old boy network
' An exclusive network that links members of profession, social class, or organization or the alumni of a particular school through which the individuals assist one another in business, politics e.c.t' 'http://www.dictionary.com/browse/old--boy--network
Clark Doll test.
The Clark doll test demonstrated the negative effects of stereotyping and segregation in America. It shows the damage caused by racial segregation and racism on young children's perceptions of themselves. The test was conducted by Dr Kenneth Clark and his wife Mamie Clark. The test consisted of a child being shown a white and black doll, then there where asked a series of question which are shown in the clip. The research concluded that the black children often chose to play with the white dolls more than the black dolls. And the children also gave the white doll positive connotations whilst the black doll was given negative. 44% said the white doll looked like them , but many children refused to pick either doll and others reacted emotionally to the test and ran away. The conclusion, the test proved that black children had internalized racism cause by being discriminated against.
However there where criticism over the study, that it was too experimental and that there was a lack of theory behind it. It was also said that because the test was conducted by a African American couple, that the outcome could have been rigged and intentional to show that African Americans are negatively stereotypes and that the test was biases.
But then this could be counter argued with the fact that they didn't want to accept the major problem of racism and that society is too deeply embedded in the structure of segregation and divide.
Summary of White Privilege: Unpacking the invisible knapsack.
In this short manifesto by Peggy McIntosh she identifies
what she states as the daily effects of being white and the privileges that
brings in America. She lists at 50 identified effects that occur in everyday
life, such as ‘ I can go shopping alone
most of the time , pretty well assured that I will not be followed or harassed’
(McIntosh,WhitePrivilage:Unpackingtheinvisableknapsack,(1988)
As you read through this manifesto you get the impression that the effects
are more like observations of how people from different ethnic backgrounds are
treated and stereotyped in a prominently white society. And this is shown
through these observations ‘Whether I use
checks , credit cards, cash, I can count on my skin colour not to work against
the appearance of financial reliability.’ McIntosh,WhitePrivilage:Unpackingtheinvisableknapsack,(1988)
McIntosh also refers to the political
race divide ’ I can speak in public to a
powerful male group without putting my race on trial’ and ‘I can criticize our government and talk
about how much I fear its policies and behaviour without being seen as a
cultural outsider.’ McIntosh,WhitePrivilage:Unpackingtheinvisableknapsack,(1988)
This demonstrates that it is not
just in the UK where there is a lack of diversity within the publicly elected
political parties.
But also she addresses the divide in popular culture ‘ I can easily buy posters , postcards,
picture books, greeting cards, dolls, toys and children’s magazines featuring
people of my race’. McIntosh,WhitePrivilage:Unpackingtheinvisableknapsack,(1988)
.
Wednesday, 14 December 2016
Chances of the UK having a Black PM summary.
In the UK parliament today there are only 13 black MPs
compared to 650 white MPs. If this statistic was a true reflection of the UK
population these would be double this number. A black child in born in the UK
today is 12 times less likely to become Priminister compared to a white child
born in the UK. This comes after a BBC
report realised in Novemeber 2016 ‘ Why a black child is 12 times less likely
to become PM.’ David Harwood (actor) presented the study in a follow up
documentary into investigating why there is this divide with in politics
preventing children from different ethnic backgrounds getting the top job. The investigation highlights are several
reasons as to why .It states that 45% of black children are growing up in
poverty , this means that they can fall behind in education. This then results in only 4% of black
students getting 4 A’s at A-level
compared to 10% of white students. So the chances of a black child being born
today and becoming primister are 1 in 17 million , however a white child chances
are 1 in 1.4 million, but then if this child has gone through private education
and got into a top university then there chance increase dramatically to 1 in
200,00. MPs who are currently in government tend to come from highly privileged
backgrounds and have been through top end universities like Oxbridge and
Cambridge. As a result they know each other and this is where rumours like the ‘old
boys network’ come from. For example when David Carmon came into power he
encouraged Michael Gove who he knew from university to become and MP, he also
gave him a job in his cabinet. Gove later turned out to be a hated MP especially
in education when he became secutary.
There still seems to be a strong social divide in race , the
brexit vote could be seen as an example of this. So it could be said that
society need to re address its views or that the government should actually lead
by example and start including people of a different gender and ethnicity in
higher government.
A summary of Grayson Perry's The desent of man.
Perry’s main aim through this book was to state his opinion
on masculinity and weather masculinity is working for us. But as he keep stating
in the book he is not writing men off. He comes from a very unique perspective
as he is male and takes part in what society states are male activities but he
is also a transvestite, so also takes part in more stereotypical female activities like make –up
and wearing dresses. So he comes into this debate on gender from an almost
balanced insight. A chapter in the book entitied Asking
fish about water , Perry consisders a male figure in society called the ‘Defalt Man’. ‘The White Blob was a strong contender, but in the end I opted to call
him Default Man….’ (Perry,TheDesentOfMan,p14,2016 ). In it he describes this figure of the
default man being middle class boys who could take possible positions of power
for example politicians. The default man is meant to embody neutrality, in
there smart plain suites and lack of emotion. But because of this approach we
have a sense of mistrust with these men, as there is no personality
being shown ‘ If George Osborne had
dressed up as a cross between Flashman and the Grim reaper instead of a business
suite when he delivered his budgets, perhaps we would have had a more appropriate
vision of who was controlling the nation’s finances.’ (Perry,TheDesentOfMan,p14,2016.)
We don’t really know anything
about the people who run key parts of our economy and other major parts of government ,’ …. I like the word ‘default’, for not only
dose it mean a result of not making an active choice’, but two of it’s synonyms
are ‘failure to pay’ and ‘evasion’, which seems incleadebly appropriate…’ (Perry,TheDesentOfMan,p14,2016.)
Male politicians like Donald Trump
are committing and being tried for tax evasion and rape. Why do we in western society
put these men in charge, when we have talented people of different gender,
class and ethnicity ready and waiting? However
Perry dose acknowledge that there is a change happening with in parliaments
with employing women but it is a very slow transition ‘At present rate of change , it will take over a hundred years before
the UK parliament is 50 per cent female…’ (Perry,TheDesentOfMan,p14,2016.) But there are still a lack of seats for
people from different classes and ethnicity. This needs to change. By employing people from these different sectors of society we have the potential to push out the 'Default man' and employ new insights into politics and make it a more inclusive society.
Tuesday, 13 December 2016
Grayson Perry- The Desent of Man 2016
This Book I have found to be incredibly helpful. In it he makes reference to theorist including Laura Mulvery and ' the male gaze'. He also talks about masculinity in a way that identifies societies male figures for example ' the default man' referring to upper / middle class men who work as politicians for example. There is also reference to movements like feminism and black civil rights and how white men tend to be the overall rulers in social sectors and Perry states that this needs to change. And his point of view is very valid I think as he is coming from the unique perspective of being male but a transvestite. And it is really good that someone with this perspective is speaking and giving there opinion on the unrest of gender equality. From reading this book I want to re address my essay question. It has made me question a lot more as to why we have in western culture this white male rule and how stereotypes of these male rulers have not changed from the corporate man in the suite decades even though we have female rulers like Anglia Merkal and Tarsier May. And what kind of effect this is having on society?
Thursday, 8 December 2016
Wednesday, 30 November 2016
Post Modernist design theroy.
Form (female) follows function (male).
1960's - beginnings
1970's- Established as term.
1980's- recognisable style.
1980s-90s- dominate theoretical
-Grace Jones(1985) slave to the rhythem- cover designed by Jean-Paul Goude.
- Book- the postmodern condition: a report on knowledge.
-Modernism - anti women and anti Black.
- The Memphis Group- 1981 formed, Diverse group of artisits.
- Culture- masculinity- MODERNISM.
- Nature- Feminie.(not modernism
Patriarchy- a system of society or government in which the father or eldest male is head of the family and descent is traced through the male line.
- a system of society or government in which men hold power and women are largely excluderd from it.
Conitiations of :
White-
-pure
-clean
Black-
-dirt
-dark.
Logocentrism- 'writing is noting but the representation of speech, it is bizzare that one gives more care to the determing of the image than to the object.'(Jean- Jacques Rousseau)
Helen Cixous ( 1967) the laugh of the medusa. she looks at the terms for blacks vs whites , Male vs Female.
Phallogocentrism- Male - Male society.
West-
-familiar
-moral
-Rational
-culture
-head
-science
vs
East-
-exotic
-Amorl
-irrational
-nature
-heart
-myth
Hegemony- not the way the world is not reality.
1960's - beginnings
1970's- Established as term.
1980's- recognisable style.
1980s-90s- dominate theoretical
-Grace Jones(1985) slave to the rhythem- cover designed by Jean-Paul Goude.
- Book- the postmodern condition: a report on knowledge.
-Modernism - anti women and anti Black.
- The Memphis Group- 1981 formed, Diverse group of artisits.
- Culture- masculinity- MODERNISM.
- Nature- Feminie.(not modernism
Patriarchy- a system of society or government in which the father or eldest male is head of the family and descent is traced through the male line.
- a system of society or government in which men hold power and women are largely excluderd from it.
Conitiations of :
White-
-pure
-clean
Black-
-dirt
-dark.
Logocentrism- 'writing is noting but the representation of speech, it is bizzare that one gives more care to the determing of the image than to the object.'(Jean- Jacques Rousseau)
Helen Cixous ( 1967) the laugh of the medusa. she looks at the terms for blacks vs whites , Male vs Female.
Phallogocentrism- Male - Male society.
West-
-familiar
-moral
-Rational
-culture
-head
-science
vs
East-
-exotic
-Amorl
-irrational
-nature
-heart
-myth
Hegemony- not the way the world is not reality.
Monday, 28 November 2016
Black is the new black- BBC
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04hr09s
'Exceptional figures from politics, business, sport, science and more share their insights into being black and British today, how they got where they are, and thoughts on what the future holds.'
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04hr09s
reactions to the election of Obama.
Tutorial
- Diversity and democracy- gender and ethnicity.
- Eton - privately educated.- ' old boys network'
- Social culture - ethnicity and rules.
- Clarke Doll experiments- research.
- social ladder- appropriation.
- General election- representation and portrayal.
- Migration- diversity, multiculturalism , colonialism.
- Brexit vote, - every vote counted.
- links between social class, and ethnicity.
- education- politics- relationship used in politics , used as a political tool.
potential essay questions.
- Most of western leaders are white and or male. By being ruled by one social class of person and one gender, what kind of effect dose this have on western society?
- Within Western politics, leaders are mostly white, wealthy and male . By being ruled and represented by one social class of person and one gender , what kind impact dose this have on western society?
- Lack of women is power, what dose this mean for society?
- By having one race and one gender in power what impact dose this have on current and further society?
- Is there a lack of diversity in parliaments? what impact so societal and cultural views have on this?
BBC NEWS- Why a black child is 12 times less likley to become PM.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-37949332
This artical questions why there are only 13 black MPs in parliament compared to 650 white Mps. If this statistic was a reflection of the UK population there would be double that number. And what the chances are now if a black child becoming priminister in the furtre. Are we still going to be stuck with the upper white class , privetly school MPs we seem to have. This articals come shortly after the conclution of the U.S elections where Obama (america's first black president) is soon to give his role to Donald Trump( white american , 70's , and has charges for rape and tax fraud against him.) Why has America suddenly gone in the complete opposite direction.
Now in the UK this article states that 45% of black children are growing up in poverty, and this can mean that they lag behind in education.
Only 4% of black students get 4 As at a level compared to 10% of white pupils.
So the chances of a black child being born today in becoming priminister, are 1 in 17 million , but for a white child it is 1 in 1.4 million, However if that child has gone through private education and got into a top uni then it becomes 1 in 200,00.
This artical questions why there are only 13 black MPs in parliament compared to 650 white Mps. If this statistic was a reflection of the UK population there would be double that number. And what the chances are now if a black child becoming priminister in the furtre. Are we still going to be stuck with the upper white class , privetly school MPs we seem to have. This articals come shortly after the conclution of the U.S elections where Obama (america's first black president) is soon to give his role to Donald Trump( white american , 70's , and has charges for rape and tax fraud against him.) Why has America suddenly gone in the complete opposite direction.
Now in the UK this article states that 45% of black children are growing up in poverty, and this can mean that they lag behind in education.
Only 4% of black students get 4 As at a level compared to 10% of white pupils.
So the chances of a black child being born today in becoming priminister, are 1 in 17 million , but for a white child it is 1 in 1.4 million, However if that child has gone through private education and got into a top uni then it becomes 1 in 200,00.
Wednesday, 23 November 2016
initial ideas.-Study task 5
Definitions: all from - https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/colour
Colour - 'the property possessed by an object of producing different sensations on the eye as a result of the way it reflects or emits light.'
Collage - 'a piece of art made by sticking various different materials such as photographs and pieces of paper or fabric on to a backing.'
Texture -'the feel, appearance, or consistency of a surface or a substance.'
Shape -the external form, contours, or outline of someone or something.
Line -a long, narrow mark or band.
Colour - 'the property possessed by an object of producing different sensations on the eye as a result of the way it reflects or emits light.'
Collage - 'a piece of art made by sticking various different materials such as photographs and pieces of paper or fabric on to a backing.'
Texture -'the feel, appearance, or consistency of a surface or a substance.'
Shape -the external form, contours, or outline of someone or something.
Line -a long, narrow mark or band.
- Line could symbolise political divide? or social divide?
- Shape , gender or object- social or cultural.
- Textre , could link to culture e.g. tribes , religions.
- She could also be technology, software and hard dirves, what shapes are they makeup of?
- Political satirical collage?
- Asethtetics all above. when applied to different materials how dose this effect the aesthetic?
- History - line, shape , colour. to particular time periods or ruins.
Modernist design theory - key notes.
Modernism in design:
-anti- historicism.
-truth to materials
- Form follows function.
- Tehcnology.
- internationalism.
Utopia- aimed to be for everyone.
Representivte communication
- Marinetti, F.T (1909)- manifesto of futurism- fighting feminism.
-Walter Benjamin (1936) The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction.
-anti- historicism.
-truth to materials
- Form follows function.
- Tehcnology.
- internationalism.
Utopia- aimed to be for everyone.
Representivte communication
- Marinetti, F.T (1909)- manifesto of futurism- fighting feminism.
-Walter Benjamin (1936) The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction.
Monday, 7 November 2016
Image through theory.- study task 4.
Scopophilia -
-Tom Ford Advert.
- 'look.... to examine'.
- The Male Gaze.
- Theorists who look into this , Laura Mulvery and John Berger.
- John Berger - “You painted a naked woman because you enjoyed looking at her, put a mirror in her hand and you called the painting “Vanity,” thus morally condemning the woman whose nakedness you had depicted for you own pleasure.” https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/2507145-ways-of-seeing - Berger, ways of seeing.
- Tom Ford advert-
- Context- would be seen in magazines and internet , possibly mass printed.
- Subject- half naked women with perfume bottle on her chest.
- Audience- Men, maybe young 20-40's?
- purpose- to sell the perfume to a male audience.
- Method of production- Could be used for mass print and would and did cause controversy.
As a response to this image , a similar image was taken with men as the subject, a protest image. As the original advert objectify's women and makes the point that sex sells.
-Tom Ford Advert.
Friday, 28 October 2016
Cop Question ideas - study task 2
Suggested
questions:
Political:
·
Illustrations that where
not fit to print, editorial, would insulted leaders and different people.
- Protest posters - against
oppressive political parties.
- Propaganda, influencing peoples
opinions.
- Government campaigns.
- Brexit
Social:
- Illustrations that have brought
around social change- 70-80s. Accepting people and changing perception and
strikes.
- Feminism in illustrations.
- Black civil rights movment.
Culture:
- right wing- how illustrations and
other art forms are affected by a government/ culture and its belifes.
·
The American Justice system in relation
to the ‘race war’ (comes under political as well.
Which theorists
Relate to this question?
·
Death
of the author by, Roland Barthes.
·
13th
– Documentertay directed by Ava DuVernay
·
Varrooom
Which
Academic sources are avalible on the topic?
·
Black
panther movement posters.
·
Polish
war posters.
·
MA168
– may 1968 school protest posters
·
13th
amendment
·
American
Justice Laws.
·
Jim
Crow segregation laws.
·
Black
lives matter.
How could
the research question be investigated through practise?
·
PRINT.
·
Any
mass production method.
·
I
would like to make posters as well but it would also be good to just mass print
shapes and forms, play around with re arraging them see if I can create a meaning and insights into the topic.
· Repetition, really putting an
emphasis on the message the image is trying to convey.
Saturday, 22 October 2016
Triangluation- study task 3
In ‘The Male Gaze’ a paper written by Laura Mulvey , she
suggests that the theory entertainment like cinema are designed to aim toward
one specific audience , heterosexual men. ‘ Cinema offers a number of possible pleasures. One is scopophilia(pleasure of
looking)’MULVEY, 16,1975.This paper was written in the 1950’s and at this
time Feminism was a significant topic. And issues like the objectification of
women was being brought to light, also a coscienous of the patriarchal society
we live in was being questioned. Mulvey specialised in film theory and in her
paper she suggested that audiences relate more to male characters, therefore the
male has power. The male viewer would see themselves reflected in the hero, and
as a result advancing there ego, a mirror stage in which the dominant male character
would be idolised, spectatorship. These women in the films where however objectified,
sexualised. They were made into property. As a result of the films trying to
feed the male gaze , strong female heroines where overlooked. But it wasn’t just
women who where the victims of this time , men where objectified too. They had
to appear strong and in control of the family, as fellow film theorist Richard
Dyer states in his paper ‘Stars and Audiences’. ‘ Sylverster Stallone to his role as a union representative at work, and
how he sees himself ‘fighting’ for his family…’DYER,187,1979.But he dose agree
and makes reference to Mulveys spectator theory,’ Moviegoer is positioned according to the pleasures of male heterosexual
desire’ ’DYER,188,1979. John Storey is also a writer in the late 1900’s who
make reference to Mulvey’s theory and paper and makes a very similar connection
between cinema and the male gaze. ‘…Spectator
fixes his gaze on his hero (the bearer of the look) to satisfy his ego formations
, and through the hero to the heroine(‘the erotic look’)…’ STOREY, 83, SAVOJ
ZIZEK AND LACANIAN FANTASY. Now it
is debatable whether there is total equality in film, I personally think that
it has got better from the 1950’s-70’s but not that much. However in the last
few decades film has had positive developments for example the film Alien ,
where a women takes the lead, and she is portrayed as intelligent and in control.
Also another male character gives birth in a way. A role reversal took place
and dose conitue to take place in films today. However I think that more emphasis need to be
put on this as I still think that certain films are still trying to meet the
male gaze.
Monday, 10 October 2016
The Death of the Author- Roland Barthes. - study task 1
‘The Death of the Author’ by Roland Barthes addresses the
power of author in the reading and writing of texts. Barthes states the reader
/ listener do not have a full understanding of reason or the meaning behind the
work ‘the author his person, his life,
his tastes, his passions.’ (Barthes, 383, 1967) The author’s personal opinions
and thoughts flatten the text and block the reader from gaining this understanding,
but also they come to the text with fresh point of view.’ Writing is the destruction of every voice, of every point of
origin’. ( Barthes, 142, 1967) So
Barthes has a point here about how everyone opinion would differ as they own personal
views and opinions would contribute to this. His work becomes a model for other to work
from ‘ … he made of his very life a
work for which his own book was the model …’(Barthes, 144, 1967)This leads
to Brathes text central theory. That the reader/ listener by coming into the
text from another point of view is actually has the most power instead of the author,
a power switch. This then brings into
question over who has authorship over the work. Is it the author for writing it?
Or is it the viewers for translating and making a opinion or statement about
the work?
An example of debateable authorship is Andy Warhol. Specifically, the Camberwell soups print. Now
this product was out on sale in supermarkets before Warhol made this work. The
design of the can itself could be said to have been copied, however he then
duplicated it many times and repeated this. Also the media used , print allows the
artist to replicate work almost identically, but authorship can be added in
colour and method of print. But is this him interpreting the product in a new
way, and voicing his own opinion on issues like mass commercialism? Barthes
theory, if correct ,is a continuous circle that repeats itself from viewer to viewer.
Therefore bringing back to Barthes
argument of the reader taking control over the authors work , Warhol has made
the cans his. He has taken an already re branded item and made it new and in
his own view. However in a Varoom article named ‘The New Is The New Old’ by Paul Davis, Davis discussed what is new but
makes the statement that’ It’s safe to
say that the concept of the new is a fleeting moment…’ (Davis, 9,2016) So
this means that Warhol’s idea was different but only new for a short time as
the product did come first and that people are continuously forming new views on
his work. As a result the work looses value and becomes the old new.
Barthes
makes some very valid points over authorship and his text central theory ,
but he contradicts him self , not sure weather incidental or not but if he
believes in this theory then we as the readers are the new authors and we
should just ignore most of what he states and change it to our own ways.
Wednesday, 4 May 2016
End of module Evaluation.
1. What skills
have you developed through this module and how effectively do you think you
have applied them?
|
|||||
I have developed my research skills a lot during this
module. My skills in finding resources and critically analysing, taking
quotes and drawing conclusions from them as a result I feel have improved
massively over the course of writing my dissertation in particular. By these
skills improving I was able to source more references and gain a wider
understanding of my subject. Also
learning how to visual respond to a self set problem, the different ways and
method to go about solving it for example using key quotes from the essay to
build the foundations of the project.
|
|||||
2. What approaches to/methods of research have you
developed and how have they informed your practical outcomes?
The main method of research I have used have been
looking at propaganda posters from the 1970s and later, also researching the
techniques of propaganda. From this I was able to find methods of propaganda
that wanted to base my work around and as a result I started to develop ideas
easily from there and directly informed my practical outcomes. I also watch films and read quotes about
Margaret Thatcher, this gave me an understanding into her life ,and the film
especially helped me understand the extent of how a powerful women became
very vulnerable towards the end of her life. Also by looking at other artist
work I gained a idea of the kind of stereotypes and political messages that
are out there currently.
|
|||||
3. What strengths can you identify in your work and how
have/will you capitalise on these?
|
|||||
I think strength in my work is the experimental
approach I had with this brief. In my sketchbook, I used a lot of collage,
print and other mediums in making images. Through this I was able to identify
the medium which were most effective. From this I went and used the print
room to create a large amount of experimental prints which helped me to
decide what kind of print techniques to use in the final print and get to the
final idea. My collages also have an experimental approach for example adding
in rolled on printing ink to give the image better values and textre.
|
|||||
4. What weaknesses can you identify in your work and
how will you address these in the future?
|
|||||
I think that I had problems in the practical side of
this brief focusing on what I was making and why. I struggled a bit with
finding a successful way to communicate my ideas and what I was saying by
doing it. For example in the Thatcher collages it took me a while to find
what I wanted to say, but I was over ambisous and tried to mix the
stereotypes of her with less well known facts. This made the image very
confusing and had to read. So in the future I think that I need to be less
ambition with the ideas and go with a clear and well structured design
instead.
|
|||||
5. Identify five things that you feel will benefit you
during next years Context of Practice module?
|
|||||
·
I think
that time tabling my time and sticking to it would help as I don’t feel like
I have done this effectively this time and if I had my time would have been
used to greater effect.
·
From doing
this first module I will have a better understanding of what to expect next
year and how to approach tasks like the essay and the practical work.
·
Not leaving
all of the practical work till that last few months. I have realised that getting
ahead with your visual journal is worth it as when it come nearer the hand in
you can look back at what you have produce already and develop it further
without having a rush to find ideas.
·
Having a
better understanding of how to go about finding resources and how to go about
summarising and analysing them.
·
Again from
doing this first module I will also have a much better idea of how to
structure the essay and how to incorporate quotes and summarise of texts.
|
|||||
6.How would you grade yourself on the following areas:
(please indicate using an ‘x’)
5= excellent, 4 = very good, 3 = good, 2 = average, 1
= poor
|
|||||
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
|
Attendance
|
x
|
||||
Punctuality
|
x
|
||||
Motivation
|
x
|
||||
Commitment
|
x
|
||||
Quantity of work produced
|
x
|
||||
Quality of work produced
|
x
|
||||
Contribution to the group
|
x
|
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)